For this project, I chose to do the Independent Activity on page 118 that asks for an image that could use better figure-ground distinctions. I chose to take an image that I've used in the past and change parts of it. When I first looked at the original image after reading chapter 5, I thought that it could cause confusion because students may not know what to pay attention to when first looking at it. I felt that the original image had too many colors and that the central idea was not emphasized enough. Therefore, I chose to make the center circle bigger and change it to black since it's the first thing I want students to see. I wanted to show that the outer circles are all relationships to the central idea so I made them all the same shade of gray instead of a different color for each one. Although the original image is very colorful and interesting, I think the revised image is more effective in showing the information correctly.
Section 2: Revised Image

Section 3: Usability Comments from Partner
Jamey,
First I think the revised image is a definite improvement. In the original all the colors are very distracting. A couple comments.1.The center circle being larger does really attract attention there first. I think that is very helpful because your learners will know where to start. The circle seems like the center figure.2.So what are my eyes drawn to second…..the black lines around the smaller circles. I would think you would want to the words in the smaller circles to be what eyes are drawn too. I would consider getting rid of the black around the smaller circles.3.The text in the smaller circles still seems very small. Could you make it larger? I feel that it is so small it shows it is not important. 4.I think if you wanted to add color you could make all the small circles a single muted color. Hope that information helps. I think that you did a good job with the concept of selection and figure/ground.
Rachel
Section 4: Original Image
Section 5: Justification Statements
When I first saw my original image after reading chapter 5, I realized that my students may have a hard time trying to figure out which part to pay attention to first. The figure (the center circle) was competing with the ground (the outer circles). Therefore I made the center circle larger and black to draw more attention to it and made the outer circles a lighter grey. At the suggestion of my partner I took the black lines away from the gray circles so as not to draw attention to them and made the text larger since they were too small to read. I liked how colorful my original image was but it made the figure compete with the ground, so at the suggestion of my partner I made the outer circles a single muted color. I chose to use complimentary colors (ch. 11). I chose blue for the center circle and a less saturated orange for the outer circles (Bronco colors!).
Good job on the project and justification. I think you made a number of subtle changes that improved the visual.
ReplyDelete